ITC iLand
The Royal Arms of Canada on the wood-panelled wall of a Federal Court courtroom in Ottawa: a Federal Court decision ordering IRCC to decide a delayed Start-up Visa application.
Court Case ReviewsNovember 16, 2026· 10 min read

Naghavi v. Canada (2026 FC 1370): SUV Mandamus Granted

Home/Blog/Naghavi v. Canada (2026 FC 1370): SUV Mandamus Granted

Answer about 15 minutes of questions and see which Canadian immigration routes may fit you.

Get your free Roadmap Snapshot

A Start-up Visa file ready since June 2024 was pushed back twice by Ministerial Instructions. The Federal Court has ordered IRCC to decide it within 90 days.

Share:

Naghavi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370 — Justice Michael Battista, Federal Court, November 9, 2026. Checked against the decision and IRCC's Start-up Visa page on November 16, 2026. This is an analysis of a published court decision, not legal advice.

On November 9, 2026, the Federal Court of Canada ordered IRCC to make a decision on a Start-up Visa (SUV) permanent residence application within 90 days. In Naghavi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1370, Justice Michael Battista held that IRCC could not rely on its own Ministerial Instructions to justify a delay with no end in sight. The applicant filed in March 2021. By June 2024, IRCC had found him eligible and not inadmissible, and his file was noted as ready for finalization. Two rounds of Ministerial Instructions then moved other SUV applicants ahead of him, and IRCC could not say when it would reach his file. The ruling comes after the Court dismissed several SUV mandamus applications earlier in 2026, including Zheng and Yim and Jin, and it shows where the line now sits.

Is your Start-up Visa application in a similar position? If you want to apply for mandamus, contact us. We are bringing together SUV applicants with similar files to apply for mandamus as a group. Send us a message and mention “SUV mandamus group”. How a group application works is explained at the end of this article.

What did the court decide?

The short version, in five points:

  • Mandamus granted. IRCC must make a decision on the application within 90 days of the November 9 judgment, which is early February 2027.
  • A decision, not an approval. Mandamus compels IRCC to decide. It does not tell IRCC what to decide.
  • Ministerial Instructions can justify delay, within limits. They must be made in good faith and be consistent with the purpose of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. Instructions that leave a file with no realistic end date did not meet that standard here.
  • No automatic right for every SUV applicant. IRCC argued that a win here would entitle every SUV applicant to mandamus. The Court said each request turns on its own facts, and IRCC may succeed in another case with a stronger justification.
  • No certified question, no costs. Without a certified question, the judgment cannot be appealed to the Federal Court of Appeal (IRPA, s. 74(d)).

Background: ready in 2024, still waiting in 2026

Seyedabolghasem Naghavi applied for permanent residence under the SUV program in March 2021, supported by a commitment from Biomedical Commercialization Canada Inc., operating as Manitoba Technology Accelerator. The parties agreed that the only reason his file was not finished was two successive sets of Ministerial Instructions, which the Minister issues under section 87.3 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA). His file met neither set's priority criteria. The dates below come from the decision.

Naghavi v. Canada: the file's history, as set out in 2026 FC 1370
DateWhat happened
March 2021Permanent residence application filed under the SUV program.
April 11, 2024First Ministerial Instructions (MI-1): a cap on certain new SUV applications, and priority for applications supported by designated entities that made minimum financial commitments. Retroactive; set to expire December 31, 2026.
June 2024GCMS notes record that he meets the SUV eligibility requirements and is not inadmissible, and that the file is ready for finalization.
December 5, 2025Second Ministerial Instructions (MI-2), in effect “until further notice”: a further priority group for teams in which at least one member holds a valid SUV work permit. Also retroactive.
September 2026IRCC gives an estimated 31 months of remaining processing. Its own evidence says the estimate does not include the effect of MI-2.
November 4, 2026Hearing in Toronto.
November 9, 2026Mandamus granted: a decision within 90 days. No certified question, no costs.

His commitment came from the same organization as the applicant in Zheng v. Canada, whose ability to make commitments was suspended from December 19, 2025 for up to nine months. The Naghavi decision does not mention that suspension. By the time of the November 2026 hearing, the nine-month limit had passed.

How the court applied the mandamus test

Mandamus is a court order compelling a government body to perform a public legal duty it has failed to perform. The Federal Court applies eight conditions from Apotex (Federal Court of Appeal, 1993), and all of them must be met. In March 2026, in Benison v. Canada, 2026 FCA 53, the Federal Court of Appeal explained how they work: once an applicant shows the first four, the burden shifts to the government to show why the order should still be refused. The eight conditions are:

  • there is a public legal duty to act;
  • the duty is owed to the applicant;
  • the applicant has a clear right to have the duty performed;
  • if the duty is discretionary, certain additional principles apply;
  • no other adequate remedy is available;
  • the order will have some practical value or effect;
  • there is no equitable bar to the relief; and
  • on a balance of convenience, the order should be issued.

In delay cases the third condition, a clear right to have the duty performed, usually decides the case. The Court asks three questions: is the delay longer than the nature of the process requires; is the applicant or their counsel responsible for it; and has the authority given a satisfactory justification? No one suggested Mr. Naghavi was responsible, so the case turned on the first and third.

A 67-month delay, heading for a decade

IRCC accepted at the hearing that there was a delay on its face, and the Court agreed for four reasons:

  • Processing an SUV application is an administrative assessment of eligibility and admissibility. Mr. Naghavi's was done in just over three years, which the Court took as a strong sign of how long the process actually needs.
  • In an email explaining MI-1 to designated entities, IRCC itself treated processing times of 37 months for many new applicants as a problem that hurt the program's attractiveness and competitiveness.
  • The Minister's 2025 report to Parliament describes the SUV program as designed to attract high-growth companies, and IRPA lists prompt processing and maximizing the economic benefits of immigration among its objectives.
  • After five and a half years, with 31 more months estimated before MI-2 is counted, the total processing time was likely to approach a decade.

Why the Ministerial Instructions did not justify the delay

Mr. Naghavi accepted, and the Court agreed, that Ministerial Instructions can justify a delay. Under Benison, policies that deliberately slow some applications for the benefit of others can be a satisfactory justification if they are made in good faith and are consistent with the purpose, objectives and scheme of IRPA. But the Federal Court of Appeal also warned against accepting a priority system as justification when it is untethered from the actual delay and gives no idea of when a file will be finished. Justice Battista found that warning applied here:

  • No realistic estimate. The 31-month estimate left out MI-2, which places an unspecified number of other applicants ahead of him. In practice it told him only that the wait would be longer than 31 months.
  • Deprioritized twice in a year and a half. Each new set of instructions pushed the file further back. If these instructions justified the delay, the Court asked, what would stop further instructions from justifying further delay?
  • Circular reasoning. The instructions caused the open-ended delay. Accepting the cause of a delay as its justification is circular, and circular reasoning is not reasonable. In the Court's words, the instructions were “the perpetrators rather than the justification” for the delay.
  • A duty while the file stays in the queue. The Minister has other tools to manage inventories, such as caps and program pauses. But as long as an application is kept in a processing queue, IRCC has a duty to process it reasonably, whether the neglect comes through instructions or otherwise.

IRCC also argued that granting mandamus here would entitle every SUV applicant to the same order and empty the instructions of meaning. The Court disagreed. Mandamus is a discretionary remedy and each request turns on its own facts. The Minister has the chance to justify the delay in every case, and may succeed in a future case with a stronger justification.

Why did Naghavi win when Yim and Jin lost?

On paper, Naghavi and Yim v. Canada (2026 FC 254) look almost the same. Both applicants filed in March 2021, both files had cleared their assessments, and both sat behind the priority groups in the Ministerial Instructions. In February 2026, Justice Darren R. Thorne dismissed Mr. Yim's application: IRCC had not refused to process the file, it simply had not reached it in a queue the instructions lawfully created. Justice Battista reached the opposite result nine months later.

Yim (2026 FC 254)Naghavi (2026 FC 1370)
AppliedMarch 2021March 2021
JudgeJustice Darren R. ThorneJustice Michael Battista
DecidedFebruary 23, 2026November 9, 2026
Where the file stoodEligibility, security, criminality and medical assessments passed by November 2025Eligible and not inadmissible; ready for finalization since June 2024
How the court saw the instructionsA lawful priority queue that justified the waitThe cause of an open-ended delay with no realistic end date
ResultDismissedGranted: decision within 90 days

Part of the difference is timing. Yim was decided less than three weeks before the Federal Court of Appeal's March 2026 decision in Benison, which Naghavi relies on for its warning against open-ended delay. But timing is not the whole story. In Jin v. Canada, 2026 FC 1080, decided after Benison, Justice Negar Azmudeh declined mandamus for a file under the same instructions. Justice Battista distinguished Jin because it was not based on a finding of open-ended delay and focused on whether the instructions were valid, which nobody disputed in Naghavi. Judges of the same court have now reached different results on similar SUV files. Until a higher court settles the question, the outcome can depend on the facts of the file and on how the judge reads Benison.

The Supreme Court of Canada granted leave to appeal Benison on July 23, 2026, and has not yet set a hearing date. Its ruling could change the test the Federal Court applies to every delay case, including SUV files.

If your SUV application is still waiting: what to check

Naghavi does not mean every SUV file will win in court, and IRCC can still defend each case on its own facts. Before deciding anything, check:

  • Whether your file is ready for a decision. Naghavi's strongest fact was a GCMS entry, in June 2024, recording that he was eligible, not inadmissible and ready for finalization. A file still in security screening is in a different position: as Zheng shows, a CSIS letter saying its part is done is not the same as screening being passed.
  • Which priority group your file is in. Mr. Naghavi and Mr. Yim were both behind the priority groups. For a file inside a priority group, IRCC can more easily show that it is moving through the queue.
  • What processing estimate IRCC has given you, and what it leaves out. The decision turned on the lack of a realistic end date. An estimate that ignored the December 2025 instructions was not enough.
  • Whether your designated organization was suspended. While a suspension is in effect, Zheng holds that IRCC has no duty to process the linked files, so mandamus cannot issue.
  • Your own side of the delay. Respond to every IRCC request promptly and keep your contact details, documents and business information current.
  • What a decision would look like today. Mandamus forces a decision, and a decision can be a refusal. Make sure your file is complete and up to date before you ask the Court to make IRCC decide it.
  • Whether a province may identify your file. On November 12, 2026, IRCC said provinces and territories can identify workers living in Canada whose permanent residence applications are pending, naming the Start-Up Visa Program, using extra nominee space intended for use by March 31, 2027. It is not a commitment to process every file. Our report on the announcement explains what is known.

Can you still apply under the Start-up Visa?

No. IRCC stopped accepting commitment certificates from designated organizations after December 31, 2025. After that it accepted new SUV permanent residence applications only from people who already held a valid 2025 commitment certificate, and they had to apply by June 30, 2026. IRCC's Start-up Visa page now lists the program as paused and closed to all other applications. The SUV work permit is closed to new applicants; people who already hold one may be able to extend it while their permanent residence application is processed. ITC iLand does not offer the SUV as a pathway. For entrepreneurs planning now, the realistic routes are provincial entrepreneur programs and the C11 work permit, which our C11 work permit guide explains.

Have a similar SUV file? Apply for mandamus as a group

If your Start-up Visa application is in a similar position (filed years ago, past its eligibility and admissibility assessments, held behind the priority groups in the Ministerial Instructions, and with no realistic estimate from IRCC) and you want to apply for mandamus, contact us. We are bringing together SUV applicants with similar files to apply for mandamus as a group.

A group does not mean one case for everyone. Each applicant files their own application in the Federal Court. Mandamus applications are filed by a lawyer or by the applicant in person, and the Court decides each one on its own facts. Naghavi's result does not mean another file will succeed, and an order of mandamus requires a decision, not an approval. Send us a message and mention “SUV mandamus group”, so your file history and GCMS notes can first be checked against Naghavi, Yim and Zheng. This article analyses a published court decision and is not legal advice.

Sources

Checked on November 16, 2026:

RA
Ramin Asadi RCIC · R407111
Regulated Canadian Immigration Consultant (RCIC) · ITC iLand Immigration Inc.
Published November 16, 2026
This article was prepared by ITC iLand licensed immigration consultants. This is general information and does not constitute legal advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a writ of mandamus in a Start-up Visa case?

Mandamus is a Federal Court order that compels IRCC to perform a public legal duty it has failed to perform, here, to make a decision on a permanent residence application. The applicant must meet eight conditions set out by the Federal Court of Appeal in Apotex. In delay cases the key questions are whether the delay is longer than the process requires, whether the applicant is responsible for it, and whether IRCC has a satisfactory justification. In Naghavi v. Canada (2026 FC 1370), the Court ordered IRCC to decide a Start-up Visa application within 90 days.

Does a mandamus order mean my Start-up Visa application will be approved?

No. Mandamus compels IRCC to make a decision by a deadline; it does not tell IRCC what to decide. The decision can still be a refusal, for example if the file no longer meets the program's requirements. That is why it is worth making sure your file is complete and current before asking the Court to force a decision.

Can IRCC's Ministerial Instructions justify Start-up Visa processing delays?

Sometimes. Under the Federal Court of Appeal's decision in Benison (2026 FCA 53), instructions that deliberately slow some applications for the benefit of others can justify delay if they are made in good faith and fit the purpose of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act. In Yim (2026 FC 254) and Jin (2026 FC 1080), the Federal Court declined mandamus for Start-up Visa files under the same instructions. In Naghavi (2026 FC 1370) it granted it, because the file had been pushed back twice and IRCC gave no realistic estimate of when it would be decided. The Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to hear an appeal in Benison.

Does the Naghavi decision mean every waiting Start-up Visa applicant can get mandamus?

No. The Court rejected IRCC's argument that its ruling would entitle every Start-up Visa applicant to mandamus: each request turns on its own facts, and IRCC may succeed in another case with a stronger justification. Mr. Naghavi's file had been ready for finalization since June 2024. Files still in security screening, files in a priority group, and files tied to a suspended designated organization are in different positions. Other judges have dismissed similar Start-up Visa applications, so a review of your file against the decisions is the first step.

Have a question about this article?

Ask our licensed RCIC consultants and we’ll reply within 1 business day.

Is this program right for you?

One of our licensed RCIC consultants will review your profile and recommend the best pathway.

Get draw alerts instantly on Telegram

Official ITC iLand channel — free

Join Channel

Follow us on Instagram to receive updated immigration news and useful information

@itciland.immigration

Follow on Instagram
← Back to Blog
10% Off Gold Card